Growing Rich Everyday... My Weblog

Enrich yourself by finding and enjoying the simple and finer things in the daily humdrum of life...




Taare Zameen Par is about a dyslexic kid, Ishaan Awasthi, who is unable to comprehend the rigors of a typical formal Indian education system that is so mindless and abnormal quite so often. However, instead of correcting itself to be able to adapt to the poor kid, all the participants [teachers, parents and the like] in the system deem the kid to be abnormal, making his life nothing less than miserable.

Everyone can relate to it, especially if you have grown up in India where most children are labeled as worthless if they "can't" become engineers , doctors or MBAs. Even this I do not blame much, because if one were to see the other side of the coin , it is precisely these professions that has helped India as a nation to accelerate its economic growth during the last decade. Science and technology are usually the tickets for a "developing" nation to propel their growth and stand up in the face of global competition. Even within a nation, it is the ticket for the lower and middle classes to climb up to the next level in the class ladder, because the next levels always represent more economic prosperity. Indulging in creativity, arts and humanities can usually be a privilege of the more wealthier classes and nations.

But what initiates the most angst is, it is even this making of "good" engineers and doctors is what the system cannot get right. What good creativity and innovative thinking can a system achieve that promotes an extensive amount of "rote" learning. It is simply churning mindless graduates based on lame exams wherein "rote" answers are the only ones accepted to the questions asked. Forget creating something, it even nips an average thought process, rendering the brain dyslexic even if it wasn't to start with.

I copy my sister's views here :) - Education does not mean scoring high marks good numbers high elite degrees in exams and certificates. Life is an exam where the syllabus is not defined and there are no pre-known question papers nor there are any most likely questions.Instead there are challenges , questions coming from all directions.
What matters most is the confidence within us which needs to be persistent in cuting the challenges like a sharf knife :) !!

There was an article in The New York times about the Japanese envying India's schools. It mentions that Japanese are amazed with the way Indian schools teach counting at the age of 2 yrs, computers at the age of 3-5 yrs etc. Why, why , oh why? What in the whole world is going to collapse if the 2-year old toddler doesn't know the numbers? That is an age where children ought to be doing nothing but playing, and not be pressured to learn such stuff at all.

Sigh !! :(

3 comments

  1. Anonymous  

    Hey Kasturi, I agree so whole heartedly - while I was always top of the class thru school - I can't recall the last time someone asked me my marks, in the last nine years!
    Besides, a nation without art, theatre, music and song is a civilization without a culture, a country without a soul. Some of my best friends and co-workers occasionally plugged a subject, or could not quite get the tables right. They are now Phd's, software developers and authors.
    Different blossoms doth a bouquet make!!

  2. Anonymous  

    Hi Kasturi! I've tagged you and Tapan on a post on six of my quirkiest habits. I'm hoping you will do the same!
    For details see:
    http://onlyshruti.wordpress.com/2008/01/23/who-me-quirky/

  3. Anusha  

    While education cannot be measured solely by the yardstick of scores, it does serve to instill a competitive spirit provided the competition is not with the student next to you but how much you can push your own boundaries. The problem seeps in when over-competitive parents-of which Indians are disappointingly many, consider that the be-all and end-all of education, at the expense of developing all other faculties of their children.

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)